May 12 (Bloomberg) -- There are more than 240 pages in the
District of Columbia's preliminary official statement to the
$510 million in ballpark revenue bonds it sold last week for the
Washington Nationals baseball team. The key to the deal is the
14 words printed on page 7 of Appendix 1, the ``Baseball Stadium
Revenue and Tax Projection Study.''
The words are contained in the ``Ballpark Operating
Assumptions'' section of the study, which states the following
assumption: ``The future owner(s) of the team will strive to
maintain a competitive ball club.''
The 55-page study was done by Economics Research
Associates, a consulting firm with offices in California,
Chicago, New York, Washington, D.C., and London. The firm,
according to its Web site, focuses on ``economic analysis for
the entertainment and leisure industry, real estate development,
public-policy analysis, tourism and economic development.''
They nailed this one to the wall. ERA was hired by the
District to estimate the tax revenue from stadium-related sales
tax receipts, one of four streams of revenue that are being used
to repay the bonds. Stadium-related sales include the sales tax
on tickets, parking, club-related stuff, and food and beverages.
Put a good team on the field, and all those taxes come
flooding in. Put a team out there that loses more than 100 games
in a season, and that nobody wants to see anymore, and you've
got a problem.
Big Increase
``Projecting attendance is perhaps the most critical factor
in determining stadium-related revenue potential,'' the
consultant says. ``Attendance is typically a function of team
performance, market size, entertainment alternatives in the
market and age and quality of the facility, among other
factors.''
ERA analyzed attendance of 15 teams that opened new
stadiums, and found that there is a 30 percent increase in per-
game attendance the year a new stadium is opened.
Call that novelty value. Even people who aren't big
baseball fans will come out to see how the new ballpark looks.
After that, ``Attendance in the following years is largely
influenced by the team's on-field performance,'' says the
consultant.
If the team does well, it will hang on to some of that 30
percent increase; if it does poorly, attendance will flag to
whatever it was at its old park.
Ticket Sales
There was a lot of novelty value to the Nationals last
year. Major League Baseball's 29 other owners bought the
Montreal Expos for $120 million and moved them to Washington
last year, where they drew 2.7 million fans, 11th best in
baseball. The team actually led their division, the National
League East, into midsummer, and finished with an 81-81 record.
Earlier this month, the owners agreed to sell the team to
real estate developer Theodore Lerner and former Atlanta Braves
president Stan Kasten for $450 million.
The Nationals' juggernaut stalled earlier this year while
the team was still ownerless, and when the District of Columbia
and baseball balked over the cost of the new stadium. All that's
behind them now. Last week, the bonds to build the stadium were
sold, and ground broken for the new ballpark, which is expected
to open in 2008.
Here's how ERA thinks things will play out. Ticket sales
will dip this year to 2.59 million, rebound in 2007 to 2.64
million, and soar to 3.12 million in 2008, with the opening of
the new ballpark. To put that number in perspective, if the
Nationals drew 3.12 million in 2005, they would have ranked
sixth in all of baseball, behind the San Francisco Giants (3.14
million) and ahead of the Chicago Cubs (3.10 million).
Happily Ever After
Attendance will decline after that, say the consultants,
and stabilize in the fourth year the new stadium is open (2011)
at 2.62 million. This is a nice, conservative estimate.
There are a couple of bar charts in the consultants report
that are contained in all consultants' reports, what might be
termed the ``happily ever after'' projections. Stadium-related
sales totaled $93.6 million in the Nationals' first year. They
will rise to $165.3 million during the first year in the new
ballpark, and stabilize at $154.9 million by 2011. After that,
there's just a wonderful upward slope to that chart, as sales --
and tax proceeds -- rise 2.8 percent per year.
That's what everyone is counting on, of course -- the
bondholders, the team's owners, the residents of the District,
the fans. And that relies on the Nationals fielding a
competitive team. All the other stuff people talk about, such as
the number of club seats and luxury boxes in the new stadium, is
a lot of noise. It's time to play ball.
To contact the writer of this column:
Joe Mysak in New York at
jmysakjr@bloomberg.net